Phone Bans Improve Learning, Study Finds — But So Far, Only Slightly
Research released today shows that students across 4,600 schools gained the equivalent of a week of instruction each year after phones were barred from schools.
Recently enacted prohibitions on phone use in schools have produced slight, though recognizable, improvements in learning, according to a new study of millions of U.S. students. The paper’s authors argue that effective bans on devices during the school day could, over time, restore a substantial portion of the academic growth that has been lost over the past decade.
But nagging questions remain about the efficacy of the bans, along with the wider impact of smartphones on children and adolescents. Given that most minors access their own devices frequently at home, even advocates for further restrictions concede that too little is known about the consequences of out-of-school use.
The report was released Tuesday morning by academics at Harvard University and Dartmouth College, in collaboration with researchers from the testing organization NWEA. It is the first national study of in-school bans that makes use of student-level data, allowing educators and policy makers a more granular look at how academic outcomes have responded.
The answer so far has been: incrementally. Schools that implemented strict bans, by requiring students to store their phones in lockable pouches, gained the equivalent of 1–2 weeks of additional instruction annually between 2022 and 2026. Measured differently, that’s about an extra two minutes per hour of class time.
Harvard economist Tom Kane, one of the paper’s co-authors, called that a “modest” uptick. But he added that student achievement fell only by modest amounts in each year leading up to the COVID pandemic — a slippage that he and his collaborators have dubbed a “learning recession.” That decline snowballed into something more worrying, even before the widespread school closures that began in 2020.
Continue reading at the74million.org.