Schools that ban cellphones see uptick in test scores

First large national study of policies shows modest but meaningful boost to learning

We’re nearing two milestones in the smartphone era.

January will mark 20 years since Steve Jobs first unveiled the iPhone from a stage in San Francisco.

And it has been nearly a decade since almost every American teenager had access to a smartphone, according to Pew surveys.

But only now are we beginning to study the effects of smartphones on learning — and that’s alarming, since test scores have suffered as smartphones marched to near ubiquitous adoption, falling by about two-hundredths of a standard deviation, year after year, since 2013.

Education researchers were not on hand to study what happened as phones piled up in classrooms, but now they have a second chance: by studying what happens amid a wave of sweeping in-school bans being implemented state by state.

In the first research paper from the States Leading States Initiative — part of the Center for Education Policy Research (CEPR) at the Harvard Graduate School of Education — researchers find a measured but promising effect of those bans.

They’re not a quick fix for the “slow leak” of student achievement. But — if sufficiently strict — they do seem to cut into the steady tide of academic losses incurred by the nation’s students, and may, over time, see students’ scores climbing slowly rather than ebbing away.

In this conversation edited for clarity and length, the education economist Thomas Kane, CEPR’s faculty director, discusses what the paper found, limits of the research, and what he’d recommend researchers — and policymakers — pursue next.


Read more at news.harvard.edu