Students Made More Math, Reading Progress After Their Schools Banned Phones

A new study looked at student achievement over the long run in schools that adopted strict cellphone bans

Schools’ strict bans on students’ cellphone use boosted their growth in math and reading by the equivalent of attending an extra two weeks of school annually, according to a new national analysis from Harvard’s Center for Education Policy Research.

Strict bell-to-bell bans—essentially locking students’ cellphones away during the school day—also appear to have reduced the number of students who were falling significantly behind in reading in any given year.

Forty states and the District of Columbia have started requiring schools to ban or restrict student cellphone use in recent years, according to an Education Week tally, and research is beginning to come out on the impact of the restrictions. The latest analysis appears to show some return from those policies, even as a previous study found limited short-term effects on achievement.

Although the academic gains weren’t massive, they’re still notable, according to the researchers behind the new analysis. Student achievement began declining more than a decade ago, as kids’ access to smartphones was expanding, said Thomas Kane, an economist and professor in Harvard’s Graduate School of Education.

A lot of ink has been spilled on what caused the steady decline in reading and math scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress, and Kane said smartphones could be partially to blame.

“It wasn’t like phones showed up and students lost a quarter of their math and reading knowledge,” he said. “What happened was around the time that cellphones became ubiquitous, students started learning less, and achievement gradually declined.”

Researchers noticed a difference once students started locking away phones

For the analysis, Harvard researchers analyzed achievement data from 3.3 million students from 4,600 schools who took NWEA’s MAP tests from 2021-22 through the 2025-26 school year. The students were in grades 3-10.

 

Continue reading at edweek.org